When to Use Group Stem Mixdowns vs. Full Stems

Understanding Different Mix Formats and Their Best Uses

In the world of mixing, the format of the files you provide has a huge impact on the final result. Whether you're delivering a fully stemmed-out instrumental, a group stem mixdown, or a simple 2-track mix, understanding the differences and when to use each approach can help you get the best possible outcome for your music.

This guide will break down each format, its advantages and limitations, and when each works best for different genres and recording scenarios.

The Formats: 2-Track, Group Stems, and Full Stems

1. 2-Track Mixdowns

A 2-track mix typically includes one stereo file for the instrumental and one or more vocal tracks. This format is common for artists who buy or lease beats or instrumentals and don't have access to individual stems.

When to Use a 2-Track:

  • The instrumental was purchased as a single stereo file
  • Budget constraints make it impractical to request or pay for stems
  • The producer didn't offer stems with the instrumental lease

Advantages:

  • Simplicity: Easy to manage and prepare for mixing
  • Cost-Effective: Requires less setup and fewer resources

Limitations:

  • Lack of Control: Individual elements in the instrumental can't be adjusted independently
  • Compromises in Balance: If the instrumental is too crowded, advanced techniques may be needed to make space for the vocals

2. Group Stems

Group stems consolidate related elements into stereo files (e.g., all drums, all vocals, all synths). This format gives the mix engineer more flexibility than a 2-track but less control than full stems.

When to Use Group Stems:

  • The producer or artist has a good grasp of mixing basics and has already balanced individual elements within groups
  • The song is polished and needs only final touches, like EQ, compression, and leveling
  • Ideal for genres like pop or EDM, where tracks are often produced and balanced in the DAW before mixing

Advantages:

  • Balance Retention: Maintains the artist/producer's original mix intent
  • Faster Workflow: The engineer spends less time balancing individual elements
  • Cost-Efficient: Fewer tracks mean a simpler mix, reducing time and cost

Limitations:

  • Reduced Flexibility: If a specific element within a group is off, the mix engineer's ability to adjust it is limited
  • Relies on Proper Preparation: Poorly balanced or clipped group stems can lead to subpar results

3. Full Stems

Full stems provide individual tracks for every instrument, vocal, and effect in the mix. This format gives the mix engineer complete control over every element.

When to Use Full Stems:

  • Live Recordings: Essential for live-recorded drums, guitars, or orchestras where each mic or instrument needs individual attention
  • Complex Arrangements: Songs with multiple layers, intricate arrangements, or genre-spanning elements
  • Unbalanced Tracks: If the initial mix is rough or unfinished, full stems allow the engineer to address imbalances at a granular level

Advantages:

  • Maximum Flexibility: Every element can be adjusted, EQ'd, and processed independently
  • Best for Live Recordings: Allows precise control over bleed, phase alignment, and dynamics
  • Ideal for Problem Solving: Perfect for addressing issues like muddy low-end or harsh frequencies

Limitations:

  • More Time-Intensive: The additional control requires more time to process and balance each element
  • Larger File Size: Preparing and exporting full stems takes longer and requires more storage

Comparing Formats for Common Scenarios

Pop and EDM Songs

  • Group Stems: Producers often balance their tracks well before mixing, making group stems ideal for this genre. For example:
    • One stem for drums
    • One for basses
    • One for synths and melodic elements
    • One for vocals
  • Full Stems: Use when additional control is needed for fine-tuning a layered drop or intricate vocal production

Live Bands and Acoustic Recordings

  • Full Stems: Essential for live-recorded drums and acoustic instruments where each mic needs individual attention
    • Example: A drum kit might include stems for kick, snare, toms, overheads, and room mics
  • Group Stems: Suitable if the band already has a cohesive demo mix and just needs polish or refinement

Hip-Hop and Rap

  • 2-Track: Common for rap artists who lease beats as a single stereo file
  • Group Stems: Useful for separating the drums, melodic elements, and effects, especially in tracks with heavy layering
  • Full Stems: Ideal when the beat includes intricate elements that need individualized attention, such as 808s, hi-hats, or layered vocal samples

How to Decide Between Group Stems and Full Stems

Question Use Group Stems Use Full Stems
Is the instrumental already balanced? ✅ Yes 🚫 No
Does the song have live drums? 🚫 No ✅ Yes
Does the producer want to retain control? ✅ Yes 🚫 No
Is there heavy layering or complexity? 🚫 No ✅ Yes

The Role of the Mix Engineer

Regardless of the format, a skilled mix engineer can bring out the best in your track by addressing challenges and enhancing its strengths:

  • 2-Track: Techniques like EQ carving, stereo imaging, and multiband compression ensure a polished result
  • Group Stems: Careful processing retains the producer's intent while refining the sound
  • Full Stems: Every element gets individualized attention for the highest level of detail and clarity
The right format depends on your project's goals, the level of control you want to retain, and the complexity of your arrangement. While full stems offer maximum flexibility, group stems and even 2-track mixes can produce incredible results when handled by a professional.

Ready to Get Started?

Use our price calculator to get an instant quote for your project.

Calculate Price

Let's Find the Right Format for Your Music

Not sure which format is best for your project? Book a free consultation to discuss your needs and get expert guidance on the best approach for your music.

Get Started
^ Resources